Skip to main content

Bell Calls for CRTC-Backed Website Blocking System and Complete Criminalization of Copyright in NAFTA - Michael Geist

Michael Geist:

“The Bell proposals (which sit alongside broadcast distribution proposals that would enshrine simultaneous substitution in NAFTA and create the prospect of blocked U.S. channels under a consent model) suggest that the company’s position as a common carrier representing the concerns of ISPs and their subscribers is long over. Instead, Bell’s copyright advocacy goes beyond what even some U.S. rights holders have called for, envisioning new methods of using copyright law to police the Internet with oversight from the CRTC and implementing such provisions through NAFTA.”

I didn’t think it would be possible for me to hate Bell anymore than I already do, but here we are.

Bell wants to make it so ISPs are required to block websites whose purpose is “infringing copyright”. Who decides which websites should be on this list? An “independent third party” overseen by the CRTC. So what they’re suggesting is that the tax payer should foot the bill to protect the copyrights of these big companies, give me a break.

Not to mention, the infeasibility of enforcing this. Most internet blocks can be defeated, just look at the attempts in Australia and the UK to do the same sort of thing. And guess who gets to pay for this cat and mouse game? That’s right, the taxpayers.


How long should a $999 iPhone last? - The Verge

No mention of the $950 Galaxy Note 8, guess that $50 makes a big difference on the expected lifespan of a smartphone 🙄


Advertisers are furious with Apple for new Safari 11 updates - The Verge

“Blocking cookies in this manner will drive a wedge between brands and their customers, and it will make advertising more generic and less timely and useful,” the open letter reads. “Put simply, machine-driven cookie choices do not represent user choice; they represent browser-manufacturer choice.”

I feel if the ad industry is this upset by this, it's probably good for the user. 

The thing is, many users don't have a choice when it comes to tracking. They can't easily stop it, and when they try, the advertising companies usually try to work around it. 


A Serf on Google’s Farm – Talking Points Memo

Good article on the pervasiveness of Google.